Bilingual Linguistic and National Identity (A Case Study of the Sociolinguistic Surveys in Ukraine)
PDF

Keywords

ethnic identity
language identity
national identity
language situation
bilingualism
discursive construction

How to Cite

Yarotska, G. (2024). Bilingual Linguistic and National Identity (A Case Study of the Sociolinguistic Surveys in Ukraine). Bibliotekarz Podlaski, 61(4), 141–152. https://doi.org/10.36770/bp.854

Abstract

The article explores the problems of the correlation of linguistic, ethnic, and national identity, and defines related terms and concepts. It also considers the issues of bilingual individuals’ linguistic and national identity. The practical analysis of the current language situation in Ukraine, defined as bilingual, is based on a sociolinguistic survey from May 2022. The theoretical conclusions of the research define ethnic identity as the awareness of an individual’s belonging to a specific group in society and, as a result, sharing values and guidelines for their worldview and communicative behaviour with this group’s representatives. According to the survey, one of the distinguishing features of how Ukrainian citizens determine their national identity is the citizenship criterion. Therefore, national and linguistic identity is a historically changing phenomenon that, under certain conditions and at different times, is determined by the awareness of belonging to a social group within the boundaries of a single state and is associated with the state language. This identity is a two-sided semiotic, discursive construction that manifests signs to distinguish “Us” from “Them”. Currently, in Ukraine, amid the war with Russia, bilingual Ukrainians almost unanimously identify themselves as Ukrainians by nationality, which indicates unity and patriotism. Nevertheless, there are no established criteria for defining ethnic, national, and linguistic identities. The significance and relevance of the situation determine the discursive construction claiming hegemony at this historical moment under these historical conditions. In this regard, national identity is believed to be a dynamic process conditioned by the discursive construction prevailing over a given period. It unites the nation when it faces challenges to cope with.

https://doi.org/10.36770/bp.854
PDF

References

Babii I. ‘Movna polityka nezalezhnoyi Ukrayiny [Language Policy of the Independent Ukraine], Aktualni pytannia humanitarnykh nauk: mizhvuzivskyy zbirnyk naukovykh prats molodykh vchenykh Drohobytskoho derzhavnoho pedahohichnoho universytetu imeni Ivana Franka [Relevant issues of humanities: interuniversity collection of scientific works of the young scientist of Drohobych State Pedagogical University named after Ivan Franko] 2021, iss. 45 (1). S. 101–106.

Blommaert J. Language policy and national identity // T. Ricento (ed.). An introduction to language policy: Theory and method. Oxford: Wiley Blackwell, 2006. P. 238–254.

Diems´ka-Kulczic´ka O.M., Malcew Je. Mowna połіtika : pro іdienticznіst´ і uspіsznіst´ u głobalnomu switi [Language policy: about the identity and success in the global world] Mowa : kłasicznie – modiernie – postmodiernie : zbіrnik naukowich prac´. 2016. Wip. 2, S. 16–26.

Dotsenko O., ‘Bahatomovnist Ukrayiny: dyskurs zakonodavchoho rehulyuvannia’ [Ukraine’s multilingualism: the discourse of legal regulations], Aktualni pytannia humanitarnykh nauk [Relevant Issues of Humanities] 2022, iss. 56, vol. 2.

Gnatenko P.I., Natsionalna identychnist i istorychna pamiat [National Identity and Historical Memory]. Scientific and theoretical almanac «Grani», 21(10), 2018. S. 164–169 .

Grosjean F. The bilingual as a person. In: Titone R, editor. On the bilingual person. Toronto: Biblioteca di Quaderni d’italianistica; 1989. P. 35–54.

Joseph J., Language and Identity: National, Ethnic, Religious. Hound mills, Basingstoke, Hampshire and New York, 2004.

John Edwards. 2009. Language and identity: An introduction. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. 314 p.

Korostelina Karina V. Mapping national identity narratives in Ukraine, Nationalities Papers: The Journal of Nationalism and Ethnicity. http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/00905992.2012.747498 [accessed on: 9.01.2023].

Kulyk V., ‘Between the “Self” and the “Other”: Representations of Ukraine’s Russian-speakers in social media discourse,’ East/West: Journal of Ukrainian Studies 2018, vol. 5, № 2.

Kulyk V., Mova ta identychnist v Ukrayini na kinets 2022 roku [Language and Identity in Ukraine as of the late 2022], https://zbruc.eu/node/114247 [accessed on: 8.01.2023].

Kulyk V., Movna polityka v bahatomovnykh krainakh. Zakordonnyi dosvid ta yoho prydatnist dlia Ukrainy [Language policy in multilingual countries. Foreign Experience and its Suitability for Ukraine]. Kyiv 2021. 312 s.

Lipka Leonhard. Observational Linguistics and Semiotics // Language and Function: To the Memory of Jan Firbas / ed. Josef Hladký. – John Benjamins Publishing, 2003. p. 218.

Marasiuk S., ‘Doslidzhennia vzayemozviazku katehorii «etnos», «natsiia», «derzhava» v konteksti protsesiv derzhavotvorennya’ [Research into correlation of the categories of «ethnicity», «nation», and «state» in the state formation context], Aktualni problemy derzhavnoho upravlinnia [Relevant issues of governance] 2008, № 1.

Masenko L., Mowa i suspilstvo. Postkolonialnyi vymir [Language and Society. Post-colonial dimension], Kyiv 2004.

Matuzkova Ye.P., Identichnost i lingvokultura: metodologiya izucheniya: monografiya [Identity and linguoculture: methodology of study: monograph]. Odesa 2014.

Matveeva N., ‘Suchasna movna sytuatsiia (na materiali masovoho opytuvannia 2017 roku)’ [Modern language situation (based on the 2017 mass survey)], Mova: klasychne – moderne – postmoderne [Language: classical – modern – postmodern] 2017, iss. 3, http://nbuv.gov.ua/UJRN/Langcmp_2017_3_8 [accessed on: 10.01.2023].

Movna polityka ta movna sytuatsiya v Ukrayini: analiz i rekomendatsiyi [Language policy and language situation in Ukraine: analysis and recommendations], ed. by Yu. Besters-Dil’ger, Kyiv 2008.

Mojeiko M.A. Bilingwizm w kulturołogiczeskoj projekcyi: fienomien otkrytogo myszlenija. [Bilingualism in culturological projection: the phenomenon of open thinking. Journal of the Belarusian State University. Sociology]. 2022; 3:81–91. (In Russian). https://doi.org/10.33581/2521-6821-2022-3-81-91 [accessed on: 10.01.2023].

Paradis, M.A. A neurolinguistic theory of bilingualism. Amsterdam / Philadelphia: John Benjamis Publishing Company, 2004. 299 p.

Stanovyshche ukrayinskoi movy v Ukraini u 2020 rotsi. Analitychnyy ohlyad [The position of the Ukrainian language in Ukraine in 2020. Analytical review], http://surl.li/ejvbt [accessed on: 10.01.2023].

Shakh S. The linguistic landscapes of Ukraine at the crossroads of nationalism and regionalism (University of Hamburg): Language Contact around the Globe / Proceeding of the LCTG3 conference /Amei Koll-Stobbe /Sebastian Knospe (eds.). 2014.

Tkachuk T., ‘Identyfikatsiina funktsiia movy v bilinhvalnomu seredovyshchi (na prykladi mista Vinnytsia)’ [The identification function of language in a bilingual environment (study case of the city of Vinnytsia], Teoretychna i dydaktychna filolohiia. Seriia: Filolohiia (literaturoznavstvo, movoznavstvo) [Theoretical and didactic philology. Series: Philology (literature, linguistics)] 2016, iss. 23. http://surl.li/envdn [accessed on: 10.01.2023].

Tren T., ‘Mowna samoidentyfikatsiia ukrayintsiv v umovakh viyny’ [Linguistic self-identification of Ukrainians in amid war], [in:] Mowa i pravo. Materialy Vseukrayinskoyi naukovo-praktychnoyi konferntsii [Language and Law. Materials of the All-Ukrainian Scientific and Practical Conference], ed. I.V. Tsariova, Dnipro 2022.

Yavorska H.,‘Linhvistyka v doslidzhenni mizhdystsyplinarnykh obiyektiv (do analizu kolektyvnykh identychnostei)’ [Linguistics in the study of interdisciplinary issues (to the collective identities analysis)], [in:] Mowa. Liudyna. Swit. Do 70-richchya profesora M. Kocherhana. Zbirnyk naukovykh statei. [Language. Human. World. To Professor M. Kochergan’s 70th birthday. Collection of scientific articles].

Zalizniak H., Masenko L., Movna sytuatsiia Kyiva: den siohodnishnii ta pryideshnii [Language situation of Kyiv: today and the future], Kyiv 2001.

Żabotins´ka S.A. Domіnantnіst´ ukraїns´koї mowi w umowach bіłіngwіzmu: niejrokognіtiwnі czinniki [Dominance of Ukrainian in the bilingual setting: neurocognitive factors].

Wіsnik Charkіws’kogo nacіonalnogo unіwiersitietu іmienі W.N. Karazіna. Sierіia : Іnoziemna fіłołogіia. 2018. Wip. 87. S. 5 – 19.

Creative Commons License

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.

Copyright (c) 2024 Galyna Yarotska

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.